Why would an advocate of the efficient market hypothesis believe that even if many investors exhibit the behavioral biases, security prices might still be set efficiently?

Answers

Answer 1

Answer:

Advocates of the efficient market hypothesis believe that stocks are always priced correctly by the market and they are never overvalued or undervalued. They will argue this is true even if investors exhibit behavioral basis. Behavioral bias is basically when an investor's decision is based on some irrational thought, e.g. they have a hunch that some stock will perform better, or they like a product so much that they believe it will be a hit in the future. According to the efficient market hypothesis, this investors that act irrationally, are arbitrageurs that want to make a profit from underpriced or overpriced stocks.

Even as these arbitrageurs operate, the efficient market hypothesis will still be valid, because their actions will make the market correct itself. I.e. the irrational actions of some investors will result in the market pricing the stocks correctly.

I personally do not believe in this theory, since stock prices are not always rational. E.g. today is November 21, and Tesla's is worth more than Toyota, GM, Volkswagen and BMW together. Why? Because they build electric cars. But Toyota, GM, Volkswagen and BMW also build electric cars and they outsell Tesla by millions of cars per year. I believe that in the future, Tesla's stock price will take a deep dive because you cannot live on unfulfilled promises all your life. At some point, reality bites. But according to the efficient market hypothesis this type of situation where stocks are clearly overpriced doesn't exist.


Related Questions

The use of accelerated depreciation:____.a. discourages investment in plant and equipment. b. increases expenses and decreases cash flow.c. initially decreases the firm's taxes. d. initially increases the firm's profits.

Answers

Answer:

c. initially decreases the firm's taxes

Explanation:

Accelerated depreciation provides for a higher rate of capital allowance on the assets that is New and Unused and brought in the business for use in manufacturing for the first time. This allowance then lowers for the other years. The purpose of this is to encourage  investment in plant and equipment as it initially decreases the firm's taxes.

whats a good job for me A. nail artist B.GameDev C. Aesthetic photography D.Anime Actor idc They all sound good​

Answers

Answer:

C. Aesthetic photography

Explanation:

Answer: it really depends on what you're good at !!

Explanation: seeing all the jobs you listed here, if you look more into the requirements and the education that is needed, see which one is either easier or what you're good in in that field, and go for that !!

i think that either a nail artist or an aesthetic photographer would be good for you :)

When a process is in control, it results in there being, on average, 16 defects per unit of output. c-chart limits of 4 and 28 would lead to a ________ percent chance of a Type I error.

Answers

Answer:

Type 1= 0.3 %

Explanation:

This is a 3 sigma limit given by ( μ±3σ) . Chebyshev's inequality states that at least 89% of the observations fall in the three sigma limits ( μ±3σ) . The probability increases towards 99.7% as the distribution becomes normal.

Normal distribution= 99.7% observations fall within μ ± 3σ

Type 1 Error= (100- 99.7)%= 0.3%

Upper control limit = UCL= μ + 3σ

Lower control limit = LCL= μ - 3σ

Products that are bought after comparing price, suitability, quality, and style are called _____ products.

Answers

Answer:

Heterogeneous-shopping products(Shopping product)

Explanation:

Products can simply be said to be services, events, places, ideas, person e.t.c.

There are four types of consumer product classes namely:convenience, shopping, speciality and unsought.

Shopping products are homogeneous and heterogeneous in nature.

Homogeneous shopping products usually need enough exposure to facilitate price comparison; they differs in style, comparison, quality and price sensitivity is high e.g housing.

Renz Co. acquired 80% of the voting common stock of Sogers Corp. on January 1, 2022. During 2022, Sogers had revenues of $2,700,000 and expenses of $2,100,000. The amortization of fair value allocations totaled $65,000 in 2022. Not including its investment in Sogers, Renz Co. had its own revenues of $4,800,000 and expenses of $3,600,000 for the year 2022.
The noncontrolling interest's share of the earnings of Sogers Corp. for 2022 is calculated to be:_______.
A. $0.
B. $240,000.
C. $133,000.
D. $120,000.
E. $107,000.

Answers

Answer:

E. $107,000.

Explanation:

The computation of the non-controlling interest of earnings share is shown below:

= Revenue - Expense - allocation of Amortization of fair value  

= $2,700,000 - $2,100,000 - $65,000

= $535,000

Now 80% is purchased by the Renz Co

So 20% would be owned by sogers Corp. So

That means

= $535,000 × 20%

= $107,000

Hence, the correct option is e. $107,000

We simply applied the above formula so that the correct value could come

And, the same is to be considered

Jarett & son's common stock currently trades at $30.00 a share. it is expected to pay an annual divident of $1.00 a share a the end of the year(d1 = 1.00) and the constant growth rate is 4% a yearA) What is the company's cost of common equity if all of its equity comes from retained earnings?B) If the company issued new stock, it would incur a 10% flotation cost. What would be the cost of equity from new stock?

Answers

Answer and Explanation:

The computation is shown below:

a. The company cost of capital is

Cost of equity = (D1 ÷ share price)+ Dividend growth rate

= ($1 ÷ $30) + 0.04

= 0.033 +0.04

= 0.0733 or 7.33%

Now  

b. Cost of new equity is

= (D1 ÷ share price ×  (1 - flotation cost)) + Dividend growth rate

= [$1 ÷ $30 × (1 - 0.1)] + 0.04

= ($1 ÷ $30 × 0.9) + 0.04

= 1 ÷ 27 + 0.04

= 0.037 + 0.04

= 0.07704 or 7.71%

Your name, address, telephone number, and e-mail address all belong in the ____ section of a résumé.

letterhead
education
references
heading

Answers

Answer:

heading

Explanation:

our contact information—which includes your name, address, phone number, and email address—should always appear at the top of your resume, regardless of which resume format you are using.

Answer:

A) Letterhead

Explanation:

Your answer should actually be letterhead. If you look up what a letter head is online it tells you it's the heading at the top of a paper that usually consists of  a name address, phone number, and email.

I took the quiz and got the answer correct!

EDG 2021

How much will $6000 be worth if it is invested at 3.5% interest for 20 years compounded annually, semi-annually, quarterly, monthly, weekly, daily?

Answers

Answer:

Results are below.

Explanation:

Giving the following information:

Initial investment= $6,000

To calculate the future value, we need to use the following formula:

FV= PV*(1+i)^n

Compounded annually:

n= 20

i= 0.035

FV= 6,000*1.035^20

FV= $11,938.73

Compounded semi-annually:

n=20*2= 40

i= 0.035/2= 0.0175

FV= 6,000*(1.0175^40)

FV= $12,009.58

Compounded quarterly:

n= 20*4= 80

i= 0.035/4= 0.00875

FV= 6,000*(1.00875^80)

FV= $12,045.78

Compounded monthly:

n= 20*12= 240

i= 0.035/12= 0.00292

FV= 6,000*(1.00292^240)

FV= $12,079.84

Compounded weekly:

n= 20*52= 1,040

i= 0.035/52= 0.000673

FV= 6,000*(1.000673^1,040)

FV= $12,078.71

Compounded daily:

n= 20*365= 7,300

i= 0.035/365= 0.000096

FV= 6,000*(1.000096^7,300)

FV= $12,091.78

Answer:

P = $6000

i = 3.5% = 0.035

n =20

Future value = P*(1+i/m)^nm

If compounded annually = 6,000*(1+0.035) ^20 = 6,000*(1.035)^20 =  6,000*1.9898 = $11938.80

If compounded semi-annually = 6,000*(1+0.035/2)^20*2 = 6,000*(1+0.0175)^40 = 6,000*(1.0175)^40 = 6,000*2.00159734319 = $12009.58405914 = $12009.58

If compounded quarterly = 6,000*(1+0.035/4)^20*4 = 6,000*(1+0.00875)^80 = 6,000*(1.00875)^80 = 6,000* 2.00763065501 = $12045.78393006 = $12045.78

If compounded monthly = 6,000*(1+0.035/12)^20*12 = 6,000*(1+0.0029167)^240 = 6,000*(1.0029167)^240 = 6,000 * 2.01171808178 = $12070.30849068 = $12070.31

If compounded weekly = 6,000*(1+0.035/52)^20*52 = 6,000*(1.00067307692)^1040 = 6,000 * 2.01327857595 = $12079.6714557 = $12079.67

If compounded daily = 6,000*(1+0.035/365)^20*365 = 6,000*(1.00009589041)^7300 = 6,000*2.01368511398 = $12082.11068388 = $12082.11

Which of the following business actions would likely result in criminal
prosecution?

Answers

Gas stations mainly for them being in the middle of no where and stacked with cash they are the most likely to be Robbed

Answer:

Gas stations mainly for them being in the middle of no where and stacked with cash they are the most likely to be Robbed

Ms. Fresh bought 1,000 shares of Ibis Corporation stock for $5,100 on January 15, 2018. On December 31, 2020, she sold all 1,000 shares of her Ibis stock for $4,550. Based on a hot tip from her friend, she bought 1,000 shares of Ibis stock on January 23, 2021, for $3,025. What is Ms. Fresh's recognized loss on her 2020 sale, and what is her basis in her 1,000 shares purchased in 2021?a. $0 LTCL and $4,850 basis.b. $560 LTCL and $4,290 basis.c. $840 LTCL and $4,010 basis.d. $1,120 LTCL and $3,730 basis.e. $1,400 LTCL and $3,450 basis.

Answers

Answer:

LTCL = $0

Basis = $3,575

Explanation:

January 15, 2018, buy 1,000 shares at $5,100

December 31, 2020, sold 1,000 shares at $4,550

If Ms. Fresh hadn't repurchased the stock in January, she could have reported a long term capital loss of $550. But since she repurchased the 1,000 shares just after selling them, it is considered a wash sale.

So no long term capital loss will be recognized and the basis of the 1,000 stocks = $3,025 + $550 = $3,575

Output Total Cost 0 $380 1 400 2 450 3 530 4 640 5 780 What is the average fixed cost of the 2nd unit of output?a. $65.b. $110.c. $140.d. $160.

Answers

Answer:

$190

Explanation:

In the case when the output is zero that means total cost is equivalent to the total fixed cost also the total fixed cost not based on the output level i.e. it is constant for all the level of output

Since the total fixed cost is $380

And, the average fixed cost is equivalent to the total fixed cost i.e. divided by the output

So here the average fixed cost would be

= $380 ÷ 2

= $190

This is the answer but the same is not given in the options

Technician A says that after an accident you should take measures to avoid it in the future. Technician B
says that it is OK to block an exit for a shop. Who is correct?
Select one:
a. Technician A
b. Technician B
c. Both A and B
d. Neither A nor B

Answers

Answer:

a. Technician A

A resume generally consists of *blank* and *blank*.

blank 1 blank 2

introduction eagle scout badge

work experience job-related skills

degree certificates personal salutation

Answers

Answer:

work experience and job-relqted skills

A resume generally consists of work experience and job-related skills. Option (b) is correct.

What is Resume?

In a formal document called a resume, jobseekers list their qualifications for a position.

A resume, also known as a curriculum vitae (CV), is a record made and utilized by a person to describe their educational history, professional experience, and accomplishments. Although there are many uses for resumes, they are most frequently employed to find new jobs.

A standard resume includes a summary of education and employment history that is pertinent. The resume is normally one of the first things a potential employer sees about a jobseeker, along with a cover letter and occasionally an application for employment, and is commonly used to screen applicants, frequently followed by an interview.

Therefore, Option (b) is correct.

Learn more about Resume, here;

https://brainly.com/question/862477

#SPJ6

Audience:

Your audience is the bank's loan manager.

Situation:

You have invented a new product and decided to start a business manufacturing your invention. You have chosen a sole proprietorship as the best choice of business ownership. The problem is in order to get your business "off the ground" you will need a capital investment. So you have decided to approach your local bank for a loan. The bank's loan manager is considering financing your business and has agreed to listen to a presentation about your business plan. The loan manager has asked you to address some of her concerns in the presentation.

Product:

Create a persuasive presentation that addresses the bank's loan manager's concerns.

Standards for Success:

Your presentation to the loan manager must include:

Rationale behind choosing a sole proprietorship instead of a partnership or corporation as the form of business ownership.
A detailed description of the target market for your product.
A detailed description of your business's marketing mix.
Identification and explanation of the customer buying motive for your product.
An explanation of how your business will be socially responsible to the local community.

Answers

Answer:

E=mc2

Explanation:

A contestant asks for 200,000 for 25% of their business, what value have they placed on their entire company?

Answers

Answer:

$800,000

Explanation:

25% of the business is equal to 200,000, according to the contestants.

The entire company value is equivalent to 100%

25% = 200,000

100% = ?

100% = 200,000/25 x 100

=$8,000 x 100

=$800,000

If coal mine tonnage can be shipped elsewhere cheaply, but a coal-fired power plant adjacent to the mining operation is not redeployable to other uses, what organizational form would be adopted by the power plant owners?

Answers

Answer:

vertical integration

Explanation:

The plant owners would have to adopt a vertically integrated organization because the plant is not redeployable to other uses and is dependent on the supply chain/complementary assets. Vertical integration occurs when an organization owns and controls it's distribution or supply chain in order to maximise profits and reduce costs or inefficiency. By controlling the supply chain, the chain of distribution of the coal mine tonnage can be improved in terms of efficiency and value in revenue.

You've graduated from college and are now working in an investment firm where you advise clients on investment decisions. Here is the information on the proposed project.
Up-front cost: $100,000
Next year's revenue: $15,000
Real interest rate: 7%
Depreciation rate: 3%
What is the present value of the stream of payments from this project?
A. $500,000
B. $85,000
C. $115,000
D. $150,000

Answers

Answer:

B. $85,000

Explanation:

The client should not invest in the project as the income stream is low and the NPV of the project will be negative. The client should not invest in a project whose net present value is negative which means its total cost is greater than the total revenue that will be generated from the project.

A customer has $20,000 in passive losses from a limited partnership investment. If the customer has $20,000 of passive income for that tax year, the customer may deduct:___________.

Answers

Answer:

Customer deduction = $20

Explanation:

Given:

Passive loss = $20,000

Passive income = $20,000

Find:

Customer deduction

Computation:

Customer deduction = Passive loss - Passive income

Customer deduction = $20,000 - $20,000

Customer deduction = $0

Jim has a choice between two jobs. Job A would pay him $15 an hour with certainty, and the job B is commission based where he could earn $12, with a 50% probability and $18 with a 50% probability. Which job would he choose? a. Neither of the jobs b. Job A c. Job B d. He would choose to exit the labor market

Answers

Answer:

b. Job A

Explanation:

The calculation of choosing the job is given below;

Expected payoff for Job B is

= 0.50 × $12 + 0.50 × $18

= $6 + $9

= $15

And,

The Payoff from job A is $15 with certainty

Now we assume that Jim would be a risk-averse person that selects the thing i.e. sure

So he should choose Job A only

Hence, the correct option is b.

which of the following is true of heirarchical clustering​

Answers

Answer:

*See Explanation*

Explanation:

Heirarchical Clustering is a form of collective data. For example if you want to find out which Soda sells more you would collect data based on reviews from customers of each purchase. Your data will be collected in a cluster which you will then organize into a valuable marketing strategy.

Looking outside the organization to examine what industry competitors and excellent performers outside of your industry are doing in a particular process is called: _____________a) Industrial espionage b) Unethical c) External benchmarking d) Hiring an outside expert e) Reverse engineering

Answers

Answer:

C) External benchmarking

Explanation:

This is seen to be a form of examining certain areas away from a company sector. Naturally, benchmarking is seen to posses four parts which include internal, external, practice and lastly performance. The discussed type is seen to be carried out after the internal is been done. It is usually done as a form of examination or test in many cases against another or other standards which the same rivals are seen to have in the same market. This test is also seen to produce factful finding in developing and adding value to a firm and whatsoever dealings they are proposed to embark on in a lot of scenarios.

You bought four put options (each on 100 shares) on EZ stock with an exercise price of $35 per share and an option price of $1.35 per share. Today, the contracts expire and the stock is selling for $36.25 a share. What is your net profit or loss on this investment? Ignore commissions and taxes. Round the answer to the nearest dollar. Enter as positive if a profit; enter as negative if a loss.

Answers

Answer:

-$ 540

Explanation:

Put Option - provides right to sell share at exercise price on expiry.

As it is an Right not Obligation, Thus, buyer will exercise the right only if he is gaining at expiry and he will gain only if exercise price is higher than spot price at expiry

In this case Exercise Price ($ 35) is lower than the spot price ( $ 36.25) at expiry. Thus he will not execrise the option.

He will lose all what he spend in buying option that is $ 1.35 per share

Thus,

Net profit or loss on this investment = 4 Options * 100 Shares each * Loss of $ 1.35 per Share

Net profit or loss on this investment = 4 * 100 * (-1.35)

Net profit or loss on this investment = -$ 540

Consider the following hypothetical data for 2012 and 2013:______. 2012 2013Money supply 2,000 2,100Velocity 5 5Real GDP 15,000 15,000The price levels for 2012 and 2013 are:Instructions: Enter your responses rounded to two decimal places.2012: ____2013: _____Instruction: Enter your response as a whole number.Rate of inflation between 2012 and 2013: _____%.

Answers

Answer:

Rate of inflation between 2012 and 2013 = 4.48%

Explanation:

Real GDP is the quantity of commodities produced in a specified year. Here real GDP is 15,000 in both 2012 and year 2013. Total money supply is the actual money supply multiplied by the velocity of money. So effective money supply is:

Money supply of the year 2012 = 2000 * 5 = 10,000

Money supply of the year 2013 = 2100 * 5 = 10,500

Price level is calculated by dividing money supply by real GDP.

Price level of the year 2012 = 10,000/15,000 = $0.67

Price level of the year 2013 = 10,500/15,000 = $0.7

Rate of inflation is the price rise in 2013. It is:

Rate of inflation between 2012 and 2013 = 0.7 - 0.67 / 0.67 = 0.0447761 = 4.48%

Splendid Occasions received $2,970 for services to be performed for the next 8 months on March 31 and recorded this transaction using the Unearned Revenue account.
If Splendid Occasions had recorded their service revenue using the other method, how much service revenue would they have recorded for the year?Sweet Catering completed the following selected transactions during May 2016:
May 1: Prepaid rent for three months, $2,400
May 5: Received and paid electricity bill, $60
May 9: Received cash for meals served to customers, $2,530
May 14: Paid cash for kitchen equipment, $2,920
May 23: Served a banquet on account, $2,810
May 31: Made the adjusting entry for rent (from May 1)
May 31: Accrued salary expense, $2,670
May 31: Recorded depreciation for May on kitchen equipment, $380If Sweet Catering had recorded transactions using the Cash method, how much net income (loss) would they have recorded for the month of May?If Sweet Catering had recorded transactions using the Accrual method, how much net income (loss) would they have recorded for the month of May?

Answers

Answer:

If Splendid Occasions had recorded their service revenue using the other method, how much service revenue would they have recorded for the year?

Ans: $2,970

The ''other method'' in question is the Cash method which recognizes revenue when cash is paid unlike the Accrual method that recognizes it when earned.

Using the Cash method the Service Revenue would be $2,970 because the cash has been received for it.

If Sweet Catering had recorded transactions using the Cash method, how much net income (loss) would they have recorded for the month of May?

= Cash revenues - Cash expense

=  Received cash for meals served to customers - Prepaid rent for three months - Received and paid electricity bill

= 2,530 - 2400 - 60

= $70

If Sweet Catering had recorded transactions using the Accrual method, how much net income (loss) would they have recorded for the month of May?

= Revenue - Expense

= Served a banquet on account + Received cash for meals served to customers - Rent - Electricity - Accrued salary expense - depreciation

= 2,810 + 2,530 - (2,400/3) - 60 - 2,670 - 380

= $1,430

Cash spent on Equipment is not expense but capital expenditure.

enthnocentrism as a barrier in cross-cultural communication


Answers

The third barrier to effective intercultural communication is ethnocentrism, or negatively judging aspects of another culture by the standards of one's own culture. To be ethnocentric is to believe in the superiority of one's own culture.

which two features of quickbooks online advanced are not available to quickbooks online plus clients

Answers

Answer:

the techniques and the earth

Explanation:

so basically those techniques help you

Answer:

unlimited accounts and Classes, Advanced import and batch entry

Explanation: These two features are not available in Quickbooks Plus, but they are vailable in Quickbook Advaced.

When people refer to cognitive ability, they usually are referencing the general overall cognitive ability, also called:________.a. g-factor. b. self-awareness. c. EQ. d. GLAT. e. SAT.

Answers

Answer:

a. g-factor.

Explanation:

G-factor: The term "g-factor" is also referred "general intelligence factor", "general intelligence", or "general mental ability", and is described as a construct that is being developed in "psychometric investigation" associated with the human intelligence & cognitive abilities. The g-factor tends to target a specific measure of "general intelligence". An individual who holds this view ought to believe that someone's intelligence can be expressed & measured via a single number, for example, IQ score.

In the question above, the given statement represents "g-factor".

With the real money supply held constant, the theory of liquidity preference implies that a higher income level will be consistent with:________.

Answers

Answer:

a higher interest rate

Explanation:

In the case when there is a supply of real money and it becomes constant so here the liquidity preference theory denotes that if there is a level of the higher income so it would be consistent with the interest rate i.e. higher

The liquidity preference theory means the theory where the investor demand the rate of interest i.e. higher that has long term maturities with high risk

So as per the given situation, the higher interest rate is the answer

Which action would a bank most likely take when deciding whether a person
should be approved for a loan?

A. Forcing the person to shut down all other bank accounts

B. Checking bank statements to see how much money the person
has saved

C. Investigating the person's grades in high school and college

D. Requiring the person to take a written test about financial
concepts

Answers

Answer: checking bank statements to see how much money the person saved

Checking bank statements to see how much money the person has hold on is the  activity would a bank most likely take when settling whether a person should be sanctioned for a loan.

How are loans sanctioned?

The financial institution will examine the application after receiving all of the relevant information and papers. Complete information is examined, from the current residence address to the CIBIL score.

The loan amount is sanctioned once the bank has verified all of the details.

Thus, option B is correct.

For more details about loans sanctioned, click here:

https://brainly.com/question/16775061

#SPJ2

Two siblings each pay 30% of their parents support so they can decide who will claim the parents with a multiple support agreemont
Choose one answer a True
b. False

Answers

B: false
Hope this helps you
Other Questions
What is a radical????? Who was the first female president in the whole globe Type the expression that results from the following series of steps:Start with x and double it. Why was keeping Israel out of Desert Storm so important? Which ideals expressed in this excerpt from the Northwest Ordinance became influential in other founding documents of the United States? Use specific examples in your response. Pls help I dont get it solve each of the following problems -be sure to watch your signs carefully -14+_=14 how are sex linked traits determined James bike tire has a radius of 18 inches.Find the distance covered by the tire in inches after 5 rotations.Use 3.14 as an approximation for .A 565.2 inchesB 113.04 inches525.2 inchesD 226.08 inchesPlzzzzzz help me anyone PLZZ LOOK AT PICTURES I WILL GIVE BRAINLIST What destroyed the grassland and forests that where once found in sahel what would be the square root of 144 is it 12? What lab tools are present in the picture? A. ring stand, ring clamp, wire gauze, erlenmeyer flask, bunsen burner B. balance, beaker, tongs, filter paper, bunsen burner C. ring stand, tongs, watch glass, flint striker, erlenmeyer flask D. balance, beaker, wire gauze, hot plate, forceps Remember the "Salem Witch Trials" and the Puritans attitude towards the King. Which statement is NOT TRUE? A.The Puritans were "True Believers" in ChristianityB.The Puritans were rigid in their beliefsC.The Puritans were tolerant of diverse or new ideasD. The Puritans were Separatists How did Helen Kellers life change when Anne Sullivan came to work with her?A. Helen was happy for the first time since she became deaf and blind in early childhood.B. Helen started feeling guilty about how she had treated her family.C. Helen understood that she could learn despite being deaf and blind, and she was eager to do so.D. Helen saw the light in the harbor that she had been hoping to see. Some things people should bear in mind when making important decisions? Practice Activity:.In this experiment, the team will need to set up three different cups and label them as A,B, and C. All three cups will get the same amount of water added to them. In order tosee how kinetic energy is transferred, the team needs to measure the initialtemperatures of each cup and record that in the data table, and then add differentamounts of ice to cups B and C. The mass of each amount of ice will be recorded in thedata table. After each ice cube melts, the team will record the temperature of the waterin each cup.o The change in temperature will tell the team how much kinetic energy wastransferred from the water to the ice.Think about how one can work effectively in a team to set the experiment up.gather data, and analyze the data.oMass Ice AddedInitialTemperatureFinalTemperatureCup A (Control)Cup BCup Find the area of a rhombus whose side is 5 cm and whose altitude is 8cm. If one of its diagonals is 10 cm long, find the length of the other diagonal. please help marking brainliest if its correct! Do you think there is anything problematic about the speakers argument? Why or why not?